Buck’s notes for improvement.
These are some small issues that could be improved. I nitpick because I care; the site is very well thought out and designed. I probably won’t have time to work on any of these, but thought I should write them down.
I find that having “edit” at the end of each section is confusing. It seems more natural to have it at the beginning, near the section heading.
Need to be able to edit/delete comments ala
stackoverflow <http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/47955/move-delete-button-on-a-comment-to-top-right-corner-like-it-is-on-stackexchange>_.
New Feature: if each section could have its own comments, that
would be boss, and it removes the need for a
“talk page <http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Talk_pages>_”
like mediawiki has.
The inline-edit seems to be missing a “cancel” button. There’s a “hide” link, but it doesn’t (seem to) revert changes.
The state on the comment show/hide link is a little messed up. It starts with “show comments” even though the comments are already shown. Toggling twice fixes it.
You have suggested some great ideas! I like having the edit on the bottom of the section however maybe we can make that configurable.
comments per section could be neat but at this point I don’t know how we would build that.
Yes, we need a cancel button, could just refresh the page?
The state of the comment section is broken on the ChaosTheory theme only, not broken with the default theme. Problem noted.